Welcome to Midlands State University Library

Court Judgements



Browse Court Judgements by court
This matter is an application for reinstatement of an appeal which was struck off the roll by Honourable Justice Makamure on 26 January 2015. The reasons for the order were delivered on 6 February 2015. The reasons given for the striking off were that there was no proper defendant cited, as the applicant had cited the Ministry of Agriculture which is not a legal persona at law. It was also observed that the applicant had raised grounds dealing with procedural irregularities which therefore qualified as grounds for review and not appeal. More

By a letter dated the 12th December 2011 Appellant was notified of a disciplinary hearing where he was to answer a charge of gross negligence or wrongful act or omission that causes loss to the employer, accident, injury, or death at work. This was in terms of schedule 4 sub clause 16 of The Collective Bargaining Agreement: Chemical and Fertilizers Manufacturing Industry S.I. 31 of 2011(THE CODE) More

This matter had been initially set down in terms of rule 19(3) (a) of this court’s rules. Respondent had not filed heads of argument. Appellant filed his heads of argument on 27 August 2012. Respondent only filed its heads of argument on 27 March 2013. Appellant had not served his heads of argument upon the Respondent. Respondent is according not barred. Both parties consented to arguing the matter on the merits and I proceeded to hear their submissions on the merits. More

This is an application for condonation of late noting of an appeal to the labour court at the applicant employee’s instance. This application follows the employee’s failure to appeal to the labour court following his dismissal by the mission hospital. The hospital and the health services board are both opposed to the grant of condonation relief. More

This is an appeal against a decision of an arbitrator declining jurisdiction in a matter before him on the basis that the issue brought before him was subject to proceedings before this court. The appellant was employed by the respondent as a Regional Manager. Following allegations of misconduct the appellant was called for a disciplinary hearing. The appellant refused to attend the hearing on the basis that his representative, one Mr Chingoka, was not available. The hearing proceeded and he was found guilty and was dismissed in absentia. An internal appeal was not successful. The appellant subsequently referred the matter... More