Welcome to Midlands State University Library

Court Judgements



Browse all Court Judgements
DUBE-BANDA J:This is an application for condonation for late filing of notice of appeal against both conviction and sentence, and for leave to prosecute the appeal in person. The brief facts are these: the applicant was charged with the crime of kidnapping as defined in section 93(1) (b) of the Criminal Law (Codification and Reform) Act [Chapter 9:23]. It being alleged that on the 25 June 2020, along Cecil Avenue, Selbourne Park, Bulawayo, applicant forced complainant, a twelve year old into his motor vehicle. While inside the vehicle applicant tied complainant’s hands together with shoe laces. He drove his vehicle... More

This is an appeal against a determination by a designated agent. At the commencement of the hearing two preliminary points were take on behalf of the respondent. These were that (i) the designated agent who made the decision was not cited as a party to these proceedings and (ii) it was not clear as to what was before the court as there appeared to be two notices of appeal and both signed by the appellant on the 28th of October 2022.The appellant quickly responded that he would be bound by the notice of appeal which appears first on the record... More

When the parties initially squared off the dispute was whether or not to grant an application for the cancellation of the agreement of the sale of a motor vehicle entered into by the parties(and other related relief sought by the applicant). However, the matter soon assumed a different complexion in the wake of the about turn made by the respondent company which,after initially resisting the applicant’s prayer for the said cancellation, subsequently acceded to the same. The dispute then narrowed down to the question of the determination of the refund of that part of the purchase price which the respondent... More

MUNANGATI-MANONGWA: An application for substituted service is a plea to court to allow a litigant to use alternative means of serving process to another litigant in a manner other than the usual expected manner of service as per r 15 of the High Court Rules 2021. The order granted in such an application is a special order and same is not granted on mere asking. There has to be special circumstances calling for such relief. Due to the absence of averments pertaining to such special circumstances I refused to grant the application by the applicant herein and called for more... More

The appellant was arraigned before the magistrate at Kadoma on a charge of assault as defined in s 89(1)(a) of the Criminal Law (Codification and Reform) Act, [Cap 9:23]. He was convicted on his own plea of guilty and was sentenced to 4 years imprisonment of which 1 year was suspended on the usual and appropriate condition of future good conduct. The appellant now appeals against both conviction and sentence. More

The Respondent was employed by the Appellant as a pie-maker in the Bakery Section. He was employed on the basis of 3 months fixed term contracts that were renewed continuously. The last such fixed term contract was due to expire on the 31st of July, 2012. The Respondent fell ill on the 17th of July, 2012. He approached the company doctor and was granted sick-leave. The sick-leave was supposed to expire on the 31st of July, 2012. According to the Appellant submissions the Respondent failed to resume his duties on the 31st of July, 2012. He only returned to work... More

The plaintiff instituted this civil action for the eviction of the first defendant from property house number,16 fifth Street Mhangura coupled with a claim of holding over damages in the sum of USD100.00 from the 1st of May 2020 to the date of eviction. [2] In her plea the first defendant claims that the property in question, should have been made part of her retrenchment package and she should have been offered the right of first refusal before the property was purportedly sold to the plaintiff by the second defendant. In addition, she challenges the existence of a fulfilled agreement... More

The applicant seeks summary judgment for the eviction of the respondent and all those claiming through him from house number 1294 Mutufu Circle, Chiwaridzo Township, Bindura (“the house”) and costs of suit. More

On 29 March, 2011 I dismissed unconditionally an application for summary judgment by the applicant. On 4 May, 2011 I dismissed a chamber application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court against the order dismissing the application for summary judgment. The application for the leave to appeal had been made pursuant to s 43(2)(d) of the High Court Act, [Cap 7:06]. More

The plaintiff has sued the defendants for eviction under separate case numbers. The defendants filed their respective pleas and subsequent to their having entered appearance to defend the plaintiff has filed individual applications for summary judgment against all of the defendants. The applications are vigorously defended. At the instance of the parties the matters have been consolidated as the basic facts surrounding the dispute and the issues are identical. More

This is one of several similar matters in which the applicant is seeking the eviction of its former employees from company houses on the basis that the former employees were mere tenants whose employment has since terminated. The former employees, just like the respondent herein, argue that the applicant sold the houses to them. More

This is an application for summary judgment wherein the applicant seeks the eviction of the respondent and all those claiming occupation through him from house number 1131, Chipadze Township, Binduraand costs of suit. More

The plaintiff sought an order for the eviction of the defendant, and all those claiming occupation through him, from House No 1489 Mushambi Road, Chiwaridzo, Bindura (the property) and costs of suit. More

According to the declaration, the plaintiff resides in Mutare. He is a registered legal practitioner practising under the style of Mutungura and Partners where he is the managing and senior partner. He is also the Registrar of the Anglican Diocese of Manicaland in the Church of the Province of Central Africa. First defendant is a former headmaster of St Mathias Tsonzo High School owned by the Anglican Diocese of Manicaland. Second defendant is a school bursar at St Mathias Tsonzo High School. More

This is an application in which the following order is sought; “IT IS ORDERED THAT: 1. The sale agreement entered between the 4th respondent and the late Samson Katsande in his capacity as the then executor of the estate of the late Christian Tatenda Kadira in respect of stand 77, the Grange, Harare, be declared a nullity. 2. The reversal of the transfer from the late Christian Kadira to the 4th respondent 3. The title deed 2004/2001 be and is hereby cancelled. 4. The 4th respondent to surrender title deed 2004/2001 to the 5th respondent within 48 hours of service... More