Welcome to Midlands State University Library

Court Judgements



Browse all Court Judgements
The plaintiff in this matter is a housing cooperative located in Dzivarasekwa, Harare. It seeks the eviction of the defendant and all his occupants from Stand No. 4356, Tongogara Avenue, Dzivarasekwa 2. It also claims costs on an attorney and client scale. The defendant resists eviction on the ground that he bought the stand from one Salijeni Likukula and that he is the rightful owner of the property. The issues for determination are whether the plaintiff is the owner of the stand and whether the defendant has any lawful right, claim or counterclaim over the property. More

The applicant is employed by the Air Force of Zimbabwe as a pilot and is based at Josiah Tungamirai Airbase at Gweru. He is aged 29 years. He is facing a charge of murder. He denies the allegation. The deceased, Lucy Duve was a legal practitioner during her lifetime. She was employed by a local Non- Governmental Organisation. She was aged 32 years at the time of her demise. The applicant has filed an application for bail pending his trial. The state is opposed to the granting of bail. The applicant first appeared at Gweru High Court Circuit on the... More

At the hearing of this matter I dismissed all the points in limine that the first respondent raised. After hearing the matter on the merits I dismissed the applicants’ application. I have now been asked for the written reasons thereof and these are they. I will start with the points in limine. More

The plaintiff Mugadziwa issued summons out of this court on 19 May 2004 seeking from the defendant $20 million defamatory damages arising from a misconduct letter written by the defendant, Shoko, which was published to officials in the Ministry of Education, Sport and Culture at Kwekwe, the Provincial Education Director for the Midlands Province in Gweru, the Secretary for Education, Sport and Culture and the Secretary for the Public Service Commission in Harare, interest at the prescribed rate from 1st April 2004 to date of payment and costs of suit. The summons was served on the defendant on 25 June... More

This is an appeal against an arbitral award. The respondent was employed by the appellant as a till operator from 20 August 2010 to 30 June 2013. He claimed he was unfairly dismissed when he was put on leave without pay and returned to find that the respondent had closed the place of business he was operating from. More

This is an application for an order to declare s 8(1) of the Immigration Act [Chapter 4:02] (“the Act”) inconsistent with s 50 (2) Constitution of Zimbabwe (Amendment No. 20) Act 2013 (“Constitution”) and invalid. It is contended that s 8(1) of the Act is inconsistent with the Constitution in that it authorises an immigration officer to detain a suspect for a period not exceeding fourteen days without judicial oversight thus offending s 50(2) of the Constitution. The applicant anchors his standing on s 85(1)(d) of the Constitution, which allows any person acting in the public interest to approach a... More

1. This is an appeal against the decision of the judgment of the Appeal Committee at the workplace. The appellant was charged of 4 and convicted of 2 charges of acts of misconduct in terms of the employment code. A penalty of dismissal was imposed. The appeal is against both conviction and penalty. More

On 21st November 2022, the plaintiff instituted the present summons action in terms of section 14 of the High Court Act [Chapter 07:06], in which he seeks the following declaratory and consequential relief: a) An order declaring that the 1st Defendant (the Trust) is entitled to subscribe to, and the 2nd Defendant (Zimbabwe Platinum) is obliged to allot to the Trust, ordinary shares in the share capital of Zimbabwe Platinum constituting 10% (ten per centum) of the issued share capital of the Zimbabwe Platinum in terms of clause 3.2 of the ZIMPLATS MHONDORO-NGEZI CHEGUTU ZVIMBA COMMUNITY SHARE OWNERSHIP TRUST MA1315/2011... More

On the 10th July 2020 applicant appeared before me in bail court and motivated his application for bail pending appeal in a robbery conviction and l delivered an ex-tempore ruling. In September the applicant requested written reasons for the judgment and these are they. More

For quite some time now the ownership of stand number 1150 Budiriro I Township, Harare (“the property”), has been immersed in controversy. The plaintiff alleged that he bought the property through Staset Property Maintenance and Service (“the estate agents”), who were the agents of the defendant. On the other hand the defendant denied the alleged sale, let alone knowing the estate agents in question. More

In this matter the applicant seeks an order quashing his conviction on a charge of rape and a further order setting aside the sentence of 10 years imprisonment imposed upon him following the said conviction in the court of the Regional Magistrate, sitting at Bindura on 4 June 2008. More

The five applicants face a charge of contravening section 126 (b) of the Criminal Law (Codification and Reform) Act (Chapter 9:23) “Armed Robbery.” The allegations are that on 17th June 2020 during the night, the 5th applicant connived with 2nd and 3rd applicants to go to Inyathi some 60 km away to rob complainant. Second and 3rd applicants are members of the Zimbabwe National Army who were deployed to perform COVID 19 duties at Bulawayo Polytechnic. The two soldiers were in full army uniform and armed with Zimbabwe National Army AK 47 rifles. The three drove to Inyathi where they... More

On 25 November 2021 I dismissed the applicants’ application for bail pending trial based on changed circumstances. I gave my reasons for that decision in court. On 10 December 2021 applicants wrote to the Deputy Registrar requesting reasons for judgment unfortunately the applicants legal practitioners cited a wrong case number. The applicants’ legal practitioner wrote a follow up letter to the Deputy Registrar on 14 January 2022. I was given this record today at 1600 hours for my attention. More

: The three appellants were convicted and sentenced by the Provincial Magistrate sitting at Masvingo on 10 April 2018. They were charged and convicted jointly for contravening section 45(1)(b) of the Parks and Wild Life Act [Cap 20:14] as read with section 128 of the same Act (hereinafter The Act) which relates to keeping, having in possession or selling any live specially protected animal. Each of the appellants after a contested trial was sentenced to 9 years imprisonment. More

What the applicant seeks by way of default judgment is an order removing the 1st respondent as the Executor Dative of the estate of the late Obert Mhere and a raft of other ancillary relief stemming from or associated with such removal. To put matters into perspective a brief background as same can be gathered from a perusal of documents filed of record will suffice. The late Obert Mhere died on 8 January 2007. He was survived by his wife Sinikiwe Mariva and four children namely, Tatenda Mhere (the applicant), Ratidzo Tapiwanashe Mhere, Charles Mhere and Nobert Mhere. His estate... More