Welcome to Midlands State University Library

Court Judgements



Browse all Court Judgements
The brief background of this matter is that the dispute that was brought before the arbitrator is non-remittance of respondent’s dues by the appellant as required by the Labour Act. The issues that were brought before the Arbitrator are as follows: (i) Whether or not appellant should be ordered to pay $58 377,32 to respondent being union dues and 15% interest. (ii) Whether/not appellant should be ordered to pay union dues on or before the 5th day of the ensuing month. (iii) The Arbitrator to determine the most appropriate remedy. More

This matter involves a long standing dispute over ownership and development of stands situated on a piece of land known as Newark of Hilton of Subdivision A of Waterfalls, Harare measuring 25 0532 hectares. The matter has got a chequered history and numerous court processes have been filed by various parties claiming an interest in the property. Historically, the land in question is registered in the name of one TeclaMvembe who holds title by deed of transfer number 4573/2000 On 6 November 2000, Mvembe penned an agreement of sale with Max Management (Pvt) Ltd in terms of which she sold... More

On 8 October 2020 we heard this appeal and dismissed it with costs. We have been asked for the written reasons and these are they. This was an appeal against the dismissal of an application for rescission of a default judgment by the Magistrates Court. Two grounds of appeal were raised in the notice of appeal. However, at the hearing of the matter, Mr Dondo for the appellants made a concession that the first ground was not one of the reasons the court a quo dismissed the application for rescission of judgment. He consequently abandoned it. The second ground of... More

The applicant was a mining syndicate. It was involved in gold mining and prospecting. In this application it sought several remedies against the first respondent in her official capacity. These were in respect of a certain gold mining block, Coronation 5, somewhere in Masvingo Province. The first respondent was the provincial mining director. More

The applicant has lodged this review application seeking the following order: “1. The proceedings under Case No. 270/19 at Zvishavane Magistrates Court be and are hereby quashed. 2. The matter be and is hereby referred back to Zvishavane Magistrates Court for a trial de novo before another Magistrate. 3. The first and second respondents to pay costs of suit at an attorney client scale” More

This is an application for an order for contempt for court against 1strespondent. The terms of the order sought are as follows;-. More

This is an urgent chamber application for a spoliation order. The applicant and the first respondent are engaged in a nasty fight over the possession and occupation of subdivision 1 of Charmaine of Dryton situate in the district of Seke in Mashonaland East Province. The second to fifth respondents are community dwellers and leaders in the surrounding areas sympathetic to the first respondent’s cause. More

The applicant seeks an order in the following terms: “IT IS ORDERED THAT: 1. Applicant be and is hereby declared to be lawfully authorised to be in occupation of subdivision 1 of Charmaine of Dryton in Seke District of Mashonaland East Province in terms of the Offer Letter issued by the 4th Respondent in his favour dated 3 January 2005. 2. 1st, 2nd and 3rd Respondents be and are hereby ordered to forthwith give vacant occupation of subdivision 1 of Charmaine of Dryton in Seke District of MashonalandEast Province to the Applicant. 3. The Deputy Sheriff and/or his lawful assistants... More

On 9 October 2017, I granted applicants an order registering an arbitral award in terms of s 98 (14) of the Labour Act [Chapter 28:01]. More

The application before me is of great moment. It relates to current events on challenges to judicial appointments to superior courts of Zimbabwe. It is common cause that there has been and there are currently on going litigations in other pending cases on the issue of the said appointments. This application is therefore of public interest. It is specifically concerned with the appointment of judges of the Supreme Court and Constitutional Court in Zimbabwe. More

This is an appeal from the judgment from the Magistrates Court convicting the appellant of culpable homicide as defined in S 49(a) of the Criminal Law ( Codification and Reform) Act [Chapter 9:23]. The sentence imposed was 5 years imprisonment of which I year was suspended on the usual condition of good behaviour. The appellant was also prohibited from driving for 5 years and his drivers licence cancelled. The sentence has also been challenged on appeal. More

At the onset of oral argument in this Court, respondent raised three (3) points in limine which appellant opposed. The points shall be dealt with ad seriatim. More

This is an appeal against the decision of the appeals committee of the Zimbabwe Platinum Mines. The appellant raised six grounds of appeal. Four of them fell by the wayside on preliminary points. A fifth was abandoned. Only one ground was left for considerations. More

This is an appeal against the decision of the appeals committee. The appellant was brought before the company disciplinary committee facing five charges. He was found guilty and a penalty of dismissal was imposed. He appealed to the appeals committee. The committee upheld the decision of the disciplinary committee. More

On 15 November 2022, I delivered an order to the effect that: “1. The application for review be and is hereby granted. 2. The determination by the 1st Respondent, which was delivered on the 19th July 2022 be and is hereby set aside. 3. The proceedings that led to the determination in clause 2 above be and are hereby quashed in their entirety and that the matter is remitted back for rehearing by a different administrative authority appointed by the 3rd respondent or his assigned delegates. 4. There shall be no order as to costs.” More