Welcome to Midlands State University Library

Court Judgements



Browse all Court Judgements
The accused person was aged 20 years, when he was tried and convicted of 2 counts of rape on a minor girl then aged 9 years, in 2022. He was sentenced to an effective 15 years from a sentence of 18 years with 3 suspended on good behaviour. He is appealing against both conviction and sentence. His grounds of appeal are basically that the court erred in making a finding that there was rape when the medical affidavit could not confirm the same. Further, that the evidence of the complainant was inconsistent as to the place where the rape took... More

The appellant appeared before a Harare Magistrate facing a charge of contravening s 157 (1) (A) ofthe Criminal Law (Codification and Reform) Act [Cap 9:23], (hereinafter referred to as the Code). The appellant was found in possession of dagga weighing 2 kgs hidden in a maize field. He pleaded guilty to the charge and was sentenced to 18 months imprisonment of which 6 months imprisonment was suspended for 5 years on condition that he does not during that period commit any offence involving unlawful possession or use of dangerous drugs for which he is sentenced to imprisonment without the option... More

The appellant was convicted of corruptly concealing from a principal, a personal interest in a transaction as defined in s 173 (1)(a)(i) of the Criminal Law (Codification and Reform) Act, [Chapter 9:23] (“the Code”). He was sentenced to 3 years imprisonment of which 2 years imprisonment was suspended on the usual conditions of good behaviour, to leave an effective sentence of 1 year imprisonment. He appealed against both conviction and sentence. More

On 26 June 2022 we dismissed the appellants appeal against the refusal by the lower court of rescission for default judgment on the basis that none of the material requirements for rescission had been met by the appellants. The delay was inordinate, the explanation for the delay was unsatisfactory and the prospects of succeeds on the merits were in our view nil. The background facts against which rescission had been refused by the lower court were these. The appellants and the respondent went onto a joint venture to operate a college. Irreconcilable differences arose rendering it impossible to continue operating... More

On 7 January 2014, the appellant was admitted to the Avenues Clinic, a private hospital run by the respondent. At the time of admission, she was expecting her first child. She suffered a miscarriage a few days after she was admitted to the hospital. She then sued the respondent for damages as a result of the miscarriage. The matter proceeded to trial before the High Court. After the close of the plaintiff’s case, the respondent applied for absolution from the instance. The court ordered that the respondent be absolved from the instance and ordered More

This is an application for absolution from the instance after closure of the plaintiff’s case. More

This is an appeal against a decision of NEC Appeals Committee for the Welfare and Education Institution (NEC Appeals Committee) handed down on the28th October, 2014. The Appellant is a duly registered private learning institution governed by the Collective Bargaining Agreement of the welfare and Education institution. The Respondent was until July 2014 employed by the Appellant as its bookkeeper. The Respondent was on the 1st of July 2014 charged with a violation of Schedule 4 Gross Misconduct offences under the relevant code i.e. NEC Welfare and Educational Institution Code of Conduct. More

This is an appeal against the decision by a designated agent reinstating the respondent (the employee) into his former position with no loss of salary and benefits. The designated agent also ordered the payment of back pay for two different periods and the appellant was not challenging the backpay which relates to the period the respondent was unlawfully dismissed. More

At the hearing of this appeal, the respondent raised preliminary issues which were: (1) The appeal was only premised on grounds of facts and thus must be dismissed as no grounds of law have been brought before the court for determination. (2) The grounds of appeal raise procedural issues and these are not properly raised in an appeal. They should be held to be improperly before the court. (3) The appeal is out of time and is for that reason also improperly before the court and must be dismissed. More

The applicant as farmer and the first respondent as miner lock horns over the exercise of their respective rights on the same piece of land. The applicant occupies a piece of land by virtue of land occupation permit issued to him in 2001 at the height of the land reform programme. The first respondent on the other hand is, on the face of it, the holder of certain mining rights over the same piece of land which it acquired by virtue of a contract to that effect with the fourth respondent. The mining claim was initially registered in the name... More

Applicant seeks the following order from this court; “(1) That first respondent shall approve the layout plan for applicant within ten (10) days of service of this order, failure of which the Sheriff for Zimbabwe shall sign the layout plan in approval for subdivision E of Arlington Estate, Harare (2) 1ST respondent shall pay the costs of this application if he opposes same. (3) 2nd respondent, the administrative authority for the municipal area of Harare, shall be bound by the provisions of this court order. More

The Appellant employed the Respondent as a Till Controller at its Kwekwe Branch. She was charged with an act of misconduct it being alleged that she had unsatisfactorily performed her work and lacked the necessary skills for a person employed in her capacity. She was found guilty and dismissed. She successfully challenged her dismissal before both the Local Joint Committee (LJC) and the Negotiating Committee (NC). This appeal is by the employer (Appellant) against the decision of the NC. which reversed its decision to dismiss. More

The court action between the parties was set down for hearing on the continuous court roll for Wednesday the 31st January and Thursday the 1st of February 2011. It is pertinent to note that a Joint Pre-Trial Conference minute had been filed of record and signed by both parties’ legal representatives. The matter was referred to trial by HUNGWE J on 28 June, 2017. As for this court was concerned all the issues for trial had been settled by and between the parties. More

This is an appeal against an arbitral award. Respondents are former employees of the Appellant. It seems that the last contracts signed were fixed term contracts running from 1st January 2012 to 31st March 2012. More

This is an appeal emanating from the Regional Magistrates Court sitting at Masvingo where appellant was convicted of the offence of having sexual intercourse with a young person below the age of sixteen years in contravention of section 70(1) (a) of the Criminal Law (Codification and Reform) Act, [Chapter 9:23] (“the criminal code”). More